I’ve never really outlined my current thoughts about the current war or about Bush lately and I feel as though I’m long over due on it.
Plain and simple – it’s time to get out. It’s not necessary to be in this war any longer. I’ve been hesitant on this issue for quite sometime, but the more I think about it, the more I come to the fact that it is simply time to leave and set up a timetable. Most people would argue that if we leave now, then the country will enter a state of chaos and will create havoc in the area.
Well, let’s look at this argument:
1) First and formost, the country is already in a state of chaos. There is no question about this. The country is in a state of civil war. Despite what the Right will tell you, there is a civil war taking place within the country. No matter what we do – this country is going to be scarred for generations and the violence will not cease and it simply doesn’t matter if we leave or not. With the history in that region, it would not surprise me to see Iraq once again becoming a brutal dictatorship and/or the country splintering even further. And it seems as though our efforts in trying to push away any Iranian influence is futile with one of the major and influential Iraqi leaders actually flying into Iran for medical tests. That should, without question, raise some questions.
According to Juan Cole, Al Qaeda only makes up 7% of all alleged attacks within the country. But while that number is currently on the low end, things are starting to get worse and Al Qaida seems to actually be profitting from the war:
In one of the most troubling trends, U.S. officials said al-Qaida’s command base in Pakistan increasingly is being funded by cash from Iraq, where the terrorist network’s operatives are raising substantial sums from donations to the insurgency as well as kidnappings of wealthy Iraqis and other criminal activity.
The influx of money has bolstered al-Qaida’s leadership ranks at a time when the core command is regrouping. The trend also signals a reversal in the traditional flow of al-Qaida funds, with the leadership surviving to a large extent on money from its most profitable franchise, rather than distributing funds from headquarters to distant cells.
This war is ruining any progress we made post-9/11 in Afghanistan in eradicating the Al Qaida network. Occupying Iraq has hindered and hurt us and is only making our real enemy stronger. Not only that, but there was a report released last September that stated that:
…over the next five years “the confluence of shared purpose and dispersed actors will make it harder to find and undermine jihadist groups.’’
It also suggests that while democratization and “exposing the religious and political straitjacket that is implied by the jihadists’ propaganda’’ might dim the appeal of the terrorist groups, those factors are now outweighed by the dangerous brew of fear of Western domination, the battle for Iraq’s future and the slow pace of real economic or political progress.
Moreover:
And while Mr. Bush talks often of transforming the Middle East, the report speaks of the “vulnerabilities’’ created by the fact that “anti-U.S. and antiglobalization sentiment is on the rise and fueling other radical ideologies.’’
The result, it said, was that other groups around the world are radicalizing “more quickly, more widely and more anonymously in the Internet age.’’
In short, it describes a jihadist movement that, for now, is simply outpacing Mr. Bush’s counterattacks.
Iraq has become a breeding ground for terrorism and being in the middle of a civil war between the different ethnic groups, and trying to deal with the Iraqi Parliment – it is no place to fight this type of war. We need to pull out and re-focus our efforts in areas such as Afghanistan and Pakistan and eradicate them for good.
Speaking of the Iraqi Parliment…
2) The Iraqi Parliment doesn’t even want us there anymore. They have now rejected US occupation and want a timetable. And rightfully so. We have been inside that country longer than we were involved with WWII and there is no significant progress being made within the country. It is time for Iraqis to step up and take responsiblity for their country and they have clearly spoken and want us out.
It has been proven through history that generally speaking, you cannot force democracy onto other countries, especially with the Middle East. The Middle East doesn’t want US intervention and that is something, for whatever reason, our politicians don’t seem to understand.
Not only all that, but now you have these very same Iraqi lawmakers heading on a two month summer “vacation”. So while our brothers and sisters are risking their lives for this country that is currently in a state of chaos…they are going to go on a “vacation”.
I don’t know about the rest of you, but that certainly rubs me the wrong way and it should raise eyebrows on why we are still occupying the country.
With all of this said. Why are we still there?
The similarities between Iraq and Vietnam are too similiar to ignore. Fighting for a shaky and questionable cause, fighting invisible enemies, having a half-hearted ally, and not being able to understand the geographic and historical problems of this region have all added up into one giant mess.
History has repeated itself and nobody in Washington seems to either care or understand.
This is not a situation we can win and it is time to set up a withdrawal table and leave. Sometimes there’s more dignity in knowing when you have been defeated and accept it rather than trying to fight for something you know you cannot ever win.
It’s time to leave. If not now, then when?
Expect a thorough look at Bush within the next couple days.