
I want a drink. I want fifty drinks. I want a bottle of the purest, strongest, most destructive, most poisonous alcohol on Earth. I want fifty bottles of it. I want crack, dirty and yellow and filled with formaldehyde. I want a pile of powder meth, five hundred hits of acid, a garbage bag filled with mushrooms, a tube of glue bigger than a truck, a pool of gas large enough to drown in. I want something anything whatever however as much as I can.
This book was originally recommended to me by a good friend about a month or so ago. I had originally passed on it. I’ve been through my share of severe alcoholism and drug abuse, by both family and friends. It’s not something I’m really interested in reliving, or wanting to read about.
I then reconsidered, and bought it last weekend. There’s been a lot of controversy about it, and what’s real and what isn’t. It’s been backed by Oprah and her bookclub, but she now “regrets” the decision (although I honestly doubt that) Is it a memoir? Is it all bullshit? Is it fiction? Is it non fiction? Is it all of that?
Let me just say, that I’ve seen what The Smoking Gun has reported. I know what Oprah has said. And, you know, what they’ve reported is fairly damning. He exagerrated, he altered some of the people, including himself in the book, he made up things, and all in all – juiced up his story.
And, to be honest, I really have no problem with it. We all exagerate, and we all juice up our stories to make them funnier, interesting, etc. and for Oprah to be “upset” about that and humiliate the author, James Frey, on national television reeks of hypocrisy and irony (especially considering if you dig through all the books she recommends, you’re bound to find lies, stretches of truth, etc. Nobody is going to be 100% truthful in these types of books, especially when money is involved)
Truth be told – none of that takes away from the central premise of the story: A severe alcoholic and drug abuser over coming his addictions and regaining his life. The allegations are more or less much ado about nothiong. It’s a memoir, and despite some of the claims made by some, including Oprah, it’s not been advertised as non-fiction, or anything like that. It’s under “Memoirs” and “Literature”. It is what it is, and you can take it for what it’s worth.
If we’re going to get critical on something – then the Smoking Gun should start getting critical on a lot of other things in this country and our society instead of a book that was eaten up by Oprah and her fans, both of who will turn on you at the switch of a light.
The book is incredibly gripping. It is intense. It, depsite all of the above mentioned things, is still rather brutally honest and blunt about alcoholism, drug abuse, religion, and life. The writing style is differant. And the story will immediately suck you in. The storytelling is interesting, and when reading about parts such as his visit to the dentist, or the way he treats his parents, you can’t help but cringe. The incredible, and vicious attacks on AA, Twelve Steps and religion will make you think. And you can’t help but admire his attitude of, “it is not a disease. It is a simple choice. I can either drink, or not.”
The book is an emotional rollercoaster. You will want to cheer for him. You will think he is a completely self centered jackass. You’ll laugh. And chances are, you’re going to be sad about what happens to certain people in the book. With all of the things people are saying, it doesn’t take away the fact that a good book is a good book. And this is a good book.
It, without question, is the best book I’ve ever read. I couldn’t put it down, and I really cannot wait to get started on his follow up, My Friend Leonard.